Sag Harbor Tavern Menu

The menu at Sag Harbor Tavern offers a relaxed, straightforward approach to classic American fare with a focus on quality and familiar flavors. You’ll find satisfying plates that feel perfect for casual gatherings, whether enjoying a laid-back lunch or a comfortable dinner with friends and family.

Highlights like the thoughtfully crafted burger, the crisp wedge salad, and the classic fish & chips showcase a balance between comforting favorites and well-executed timeless dishes. There’s also a thoughtful touch of unique options, such as shrimp cocktail and cheese balls, which complement the main selections and add variety without complicating the menu.

Many guests appreciate the simplicity of the menu that fits seamlessly with the warm and inviting atmosphere of the tavern. It’s a place where you can settle in on the covered deck with a plate of croquettes or finish your meal with a slice of rainbow cookie—perfectly at ease and unhurried. These dishes are ideal for both lively conversations or quiet moments spent enjoying the seasonal rhythms of Sag Harbor.